How Much Are My Sports Cards Worth?

A sports card is worth what someone recently paid for the same card in the same condition. Here is how to find that number for yours, and the five details that move it the most.

Short answer: Identify the exact card (player, year, set, card number and any parallel), judge its condition honestly, then look at what that same card has sold for recently, not what sellers are asking. Rookie cards, low serial numbers, autographs and high grades are what push a card from a dollar to real money.

Have the card in front of you? Cardchase identifies it from a photo and shows a value range built from its sales over the last 90 days.

Get the app

Step 1: Identify the exact card

"A 2018 card of a famous player" is not enough to price anything. The same player can have dozens of cards in one year, across different brands and sets, and each set can have many versions of the same card. You need five details:

If the card has an autograph or a piece of jersey (a relic or patch), note that too. Each of these is effectively a different card with its own price.

Cardchase card page listing year, set, card number and parallel for a sample card
Cardchase reads these details from the photo. Add the back for the card number.

Step 2: Know what drives the price

Once you know which card you have, five things decide most of its value.

FactorWhy it matters
The playerHall of Famers, current stars and hyped young players carry the market. Most cards of most players sell for very little.
Rookie cardA player's rookie card is usually the most wanted card of their career. Modern rookie cards carry an RC mark.
ScarcityParallels, short prints and serial-numbered cards are rarer than the base card. A card numbered /10 is a different market from the same card unnumbered.
ConditionSharp corners, clean edges, a clean surface and good centering. Small flaws can cut a raw card's price, and a top grade can multiply it.
EraOlder cards survived in smaller numbers. Cards from the late 1980s and early 1990s were mass produced, so most are common.
About the "junk wax" era. Roughly 1987 to the early 1990s, card makers printed so many cards that most of them are still easy to find today. If your box is full of cards from those years, expect most of them to be worth little, and look for the few key rookies and the cards in exceptional condition.

Step 3: Judge the condition honestly

Collectors and graders look at four things. Check them under a bright light, tilting the card so reflections show the surface.

Be strict. Most cards that look perfect at arm's length have small flaws close up, and buyers price those in. If the card is already graded, the grade on the slab is the condition you compare against.

Step 4: Compare recent sold prices

This is the step that turns guesses into a number. Look for completed sales of the exact card, in the same condition or grade, from the last few months.

  1. Search eBay for the year, set, player and card number, then turn on the Sold items filter. Active listings only show asking prices, and many never sell.
  2. Throw out sales that are not your card: a different parallel, a graded copy when yours is raw, a lot of several cards.
  3. Look at a range of sales rather than the single highest one. A typical value sits in the middle of recent sales.
  4. Check the dates. Prices for active players move with their season, so a sale from two years ago may be far off today.

Printed price guides are a starting point, but they lag the market. Recent sales are what a buyer will pay you today.

Cardchase showing graded values and a list of recent sales with dates and prices for a sample card
Cardchase lists the recent sales behind a card's value, plus what it sells for graded.

Step 5: Decide what to do with it

With a realistic value in hand, sort your cards into three piles:

Protect anything in the last two piles: a soft sleeve first, then a rigid holder, and keep it out of sunlight and damp.

Frequently asked questions

Are old sports cards worth money?
Some are. Cards from before the 1980s were printed in smaller numbers and fewer survived in good shape, so stars and rookies from that era can sell for a lot. Most cards from the late 1980s and early 1990s were printed in huge quantities and sell for little, apart from a few key rookies and high grades.
Should I use eBay listings to price my card?
Use sold listings, not active ones. An active listing only shows what a seller hopes to get. On eBay, filter the search to Sold items, then match the exact card, parallel and condition before you compare prices.
Why do two copies of the same card sell for very different prices?
Usually because they are not really the same: one may be a parallel or numbered version, one may be graded, or the condition differs. Centering, corners and surface can change a raw card's price a lot, and a high grade from a grading company can multiply it.
How can I check a lot of cards quickly?
Sort out the obvious stars, rookies, numbered cards and parallels first, then scan those. A scanner app such as Cardchase identifies each card and shows a value range from its recent sales, so you only research the cards that are worth it.

Sources

See what your card sells for

Scan it with Cardchase to identify the exact card and see a value range from its recent sales.

Download on the App Store